Capitalism in Criminal Mode

 Raúl Zibechi

In Latin America a criminal or mafia capitalism is expanding exponentially, in whose practices the differences between formality, informality and crime are dissolving, as the Peruvian researcher Francisco Durand maintains and as the Argentine Marcelo Colussi has previously analyzed  (

Each time we have more data and studies that evidence the modes in which this predatory and criminal capitalism operates that, evidently, is the form that the system assumes in this period. The Quehacer magazine, Number 10, from the Desco Center in Lima, highlights in its July edition that illegal gold mining exported no less than 3.9 billion dollars in 2020, surpassing drug trafficking (

At the same time, Bolivian senator Rodrigo Paz points out that his country is “under siege by the gold, contraband and drug trafficking mafias, which add up to a staggering 7.5 billion dollars ( Drug trafficking contributes US$ 2.5 billion per year, contraband US$ 2 billion and gold US$ 3 billion. The government, not being able to access external loans, lets these resources flow because they move the national economy,” he tweeted.

To get an idea of the significance of these figures, the 7.5 billion dollars of illegal economies should be compared with the 9 billion dollars of total exports of the country. An incredible proportion that reveals the transcendence of the mafia economies. Illegal gold has displaced drug trafficking in both countries, even though Peru is the world’s second largest producer of coca and cocaine.

What is more significant, however, is how the illegal gold circuit works until it becomes legal gold. In Peru alone, there are 250,000 informal or artisanal miners who live in terrible conditions, are extorted and abused by intermediaries, until they reach the collectors. Both legal and illegal miners participate in the extraction and commercialization process, and there is a fine line between the two, as often the same collector buys in both markets.

Processing plants usually have double accounting, to access both legal and illegal ore. The gold converted into ingots or jewelry goes to the two most important final destinations: Switzerland and the United States. The former imports 70 percent of the world’s gold. Bolivia and Peru produce almost 30 percent of the gold illegally, a portion that reaches 77 percent in Ecuador, 80 percent in Colombia and 91 percent in Venezuela, according to the book Informal Mining in Peru (

This book reproduces a fragment of the work of the Swiss criminologist Mark Pieth, who highlights the contrast between La Rinconada, in Puno, “at more than 5 thousand meters high and with temperatures of minus 22 degrees, where 60 thousand gold prospectors squeeze into a town that 25 years ago was home to only 25 families.”

In that village “an unbearable stench of urine and human feces” dominates and the living and working conditions are “horrendous.” This reality is contrasted with “the glamor of gold in Switzerland,” where the Swatch watch company “spends 50 million Swiss francs annually, just to present its new gold watches, and beautiful models present jewelry for the enjoyment of those who can afford them” (p. 73).

Mafia capitalism causes enormous environmental and social damages, such as pollution and deforestation, homicides and disappearances, rapes and femicides, perpetrated by the mafias. One of its consequences is human trafficking for various purposes: sexual and labor exploitation, sale of children and organ trafficking. In mafia capitalism, people are just another commodity that can be torn to pieces with total impunity by state complicity.

Finally, we should answer a question that allows us to complete the picture, one that researchers in general do not ask: what is the State that corresponds to this mafia capitalism, which destroys everything to accumulate more and more capital?

It is a State dedicated to war, to dispossession against those at the bottom. But it has a particularity that differentiates it from the dictatorships that devastated our region: it paints itself with democratic colors, it calls elections despite the fact that there are fewer and fewer freedoms, as monopolies block freedom of information and expression. In short: a criminal-electoral State.

Those who pretend to be a government must know that they will administrate a criminal and predatory capitalism, impossible to regulate. That’s why the progressive rulers continue with extractivism and large infrastructure works, and look the other way when the murders of social leaders take place.

Looking away is one way of letting go, as Switzerland does when it imports gold bathed in blood and death. Asked why Switzerland continues to import this gold, Mark Pieth concludes: “They want to do trade, to make an island of pirates” (p. 74).

Originally Published in Spanish by La Jornada, Friday, December 30, 2022 and Re-Published with English interpretation by the Chiapas Support Committee and re-posted by Schools for Chiapas.

Want to receive our weekly blog digest in your inbox?

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top